Duke University
Generative AI has made content abundant and judgment scarce. We study how people judge and discern in this new environment, with “slop”, the word that emerged almost overnight for unwanted AI content, as our central case. Slop is less a property of content than a social judgment: what one community dismisses, another embraces, and the label travels, hardens, and gets fought over. We measure these judgments at scale on platforms like Reddit, run experiments on how making AI content changes what people value, and ask how new evaluative capacities, human and computational, might be built to match.
All stories are social, and so is creativity: what counts as original or moving is decided by communities of readers who share conventions and argue over them. Current systems optimize for a single generic reader, an aggregate that quietly reproduces what is already dominant. We ask whether reader difference can be modeled instead. Can populations of AI agents, grounded in real readers, simulate an interpretive community, with its shared tastes, its disputes, and its sense of what is new? What does such a simulation capture about collective judgment, and what does it miss? We use these simulated communities to evaluate AI writing and to surface their responses back to writers, so that AI storytelling answers to actual audiences rather than to no one.
We study what happens when LLMs are deployed at scale on live platforms like Reddit, Substack, and Spotify, and what their increasingly obvious problems — homogenization, model collapse — do to communication and creativity in the wild. We track how AI content spreads through online communities, identify which models are doing the writing, and audit whether streaming recommendations treat AI-made music differently from human artists. Model homogenization is well documented, but whether it produces cultural homogenization is an open question, and one that needs evidence from how people actually make and consume culture. We also study detection. Does it work, or does it mostly punish the wrong people? And how does the suspicion that anything might be machine-made change what artists create and whom audiences trust?